Limitations of hand sanitizers

May 1, 2013

 

Q: What are the limitations of hand sanitizers?

A: While the Centers for Disease Control has credited hand sanitizers with minimizing the severity of the flu outbreak last year, there are some important organisms that cannot be killed by any type of hand sanitizer. Dermatologists should know that hand sanitizers do not kill anthrax, which was an organism of great concern several years ago. Further, hand sanitizers are not effective against Clostridium difficile, which has become another antibiotic-resistant organism.

Since there is no mechanical rinsing with hand sanitizers, they do not clean visible dirt from the hands. This means that hand sanitizers are not good if food or other environmental debris are present. Essentially they are good at intermittently cleaning hands that are basically clean, but might contain some microorganisms. For example, they are to good sanitize the hands after shaking hands, touching a contaminated bathroom door handle, or if soap and water are not available.

More conundrums

Which hand sanitizer is best to use in my office?

Which hand sanitizers are most practical and effective?

What is a hair serum and should I recommend one?

What is the NMF? How does it affect the skin?